Ollie vs The Farmer’s Dog: Which is the Best Fresh Dog Food Online?

2
This article contains affiliate links: see more
ollie vs the farmers dog - which is the best fresh dog food

Sophie Anderson

Today’s dog owners are much more informed about their dog’s health and well-being than they were even a few years ago.

Your dog may be doing fine or they may be suffering from health issues such as allergies, digestion problems or even cancer.

Whatever your situation you are probably thinking along the same lines as a lot of fur parents…that dogs, like us, need good quality food to help them stay well.

Many traditional dried dog foods, while very convenient and affordable, have a few key drawbacks:

  1. Quality of ingredients used. They often use ‘protein fillers’ like soy or low quality meats.
  2. Method of cooking at high temperatures. This is to dry out the food to make it into longer lasting pellets but unfortunately it also strips the ingredients of many of their nutrients.
  3. Additives and preservatives. To help give dried foods a longer shelf life, many additives and preservatives are often included. Over time these could increase the risk of health problems like immune diseases and cancers.

These concerns are making more dog owners take a closer look at the ingredients in their food. And may are switch to fresh dog food as a result.

Here we review 2 of the best fresh dog food delivery subscriptions Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog. By preparing carefully balanced dog meals using fresh, human-grade ingredients, these brands are making us rethink what we should expect from ‘pet food’.

Their recipes are signed off by veterinary nutritionists to ensure that they give your dog all the nutrients necessary for long term consumption. And they’re delivered to your door in refrigerated boxes to be served while fresh.

See how they compare to each other in the table below, to decide which works best for you and your pup.

In this comparison I will discuss:

  • Ollie vs The Farmer’s Dog: Comparison Table
  • Ollie Dog Food Review
  • The Farmer’s Dog Food Review
  • Which is best, Ollie or The Farmer’s Dog?

Ollie vs The Farmer’s Dog: Comparison Table

Before we review each fresh dog food service separately, let’s take a look at how they compare side by side:

Ingredients Human-grade ingredients.
High-quality meat.
Sourced from family run farms in the US and Australia.
Hormone-free chicken
Fresh fruit and vegetables, gently cooked to keep nutrients.
Superfoods like chia seeds
Human-grade meat and veggies
Prepared in USDA kitchens 
Free From Fillers (soy, corn or wheat)
By-products
Hormones
Artificial flavors
Preservatives
Preservatives
Protein “meals”
Hormones or fillers
Brown pellets
Protein Content in Meals minimum 9-11%
(depending on meal selected)
minimum 9-11%
(depending on meal selected)
Price Range
(USD)
$3 -$13 a day depending on size, breed and other details.
Get a personalised quote
$2-$12 a day depending on size, breed and other details.
Get a personalised quote
Shipping Cost Free within the US Free within the US
Customised Based On Weight
Breed
Age
Gender
Spayed
Neutered
Energy Level
Body Shape
Allergies
Breed
Sex
Weight
Age
Spayed or not
Body shape
Activity level
Specific health issues including allergies
Recipes Created By Board-certified veterinary nutritionists. Board-certified veterinary nutritionists.
Meal Options 4 recipes:
Beef
Chicken
Turkey
Lamb
3 recipes:
Beef
Turkey
Pork
Treat Options Savory Beef Strips
Sweet Potato Slices
Tasty Chicken Strips
Trusty Turkey Strips
No
Meet AAFCO and USDA standards Yes Yes
Meal Storage
14 days in the fridge unopened.
3-4 months in the freezer.
4 days in the fridge.
4 months in the freezer.
Reviews  4.4 out of 5 stars from 416 reviews. 4.6 out of 5 stars from 1,101 reviews.
Special Offers 50% Off your first box 50% Off your first box
Money-back guarantee on first meal? 100% money-back guarantee. 100% money-back guarantee if you agree to donate the food to an animal shelter.
Websites Ollie Meals The Farmer’s Dog

Ollie meal review - best fresh dog food

Ollie Fresh Dog Meals Review

Ollie was founded by 3 dog owners and lovers, Alex Douzet, Gabby Sloane and Randy Jimenez.

They began Ollie in 2016 because they saw the value in homemade dog food. They couldn’t see why freshly cooked food wasn’t available to dogs and their owners as a pet food option.

Since Ollie was founded in 2016 it has only grown. Their reviews are full of stories of transformations in the dogs they serve.

What’s Great About Ollie’s Meals?

Ollie pride themselves on a few key qualities of their meals:

1

1

Human-Grade Ingredients in Their Meals

They are certified throughout the US are makers of ‘human-grade pet food‘.

So you’re guaranteed it’s good enough for people to eat.

2

2

Grain Free Recipes

They have the option of entirely grain free recipes like their Healthy Turkey Feast which has:

Protein: Turkey breast and turkey liver.
Other Ingredients: blueberries, pumpkin, coconut oil, kale, carrots, lentils, cod liver oil and vitamin E.

3

3

Quality Meats and High Protein Content

As meat is the key component in any dog meal, it’s important this it is a quality meat rather than scraps or protein fillers.

Their beef and lamb are sourced from US and Australian farms. Their chicken is certified hormone-free.

As a minimum their meals will contain 9%-11% protein content, depending on the recipe.

What Meal Options Does Ollie Have?

They offer 4 different meal options. Here’s a quick summary:

  1. Beef recipe: Beef, beef heart, sweet potato, peas, potato, beef kidney, carrot, beef liver, spinach, chia seed, blueberries, fish oil, vitamin supplements.
    Minimum protein level: 9%.
  2. Chicken recipe: Chicken, chicken gizzard, carrots, peas, chicken liver, rice, chia seeds, spinach, potatoes, whole dried eggs, vitamin supplements.
    Minimum protein level: 10%.
  3. Turkey recipe: Turkey breast, turkey liver, kale, carrots, lentils, blueberries, coconut oil, pumpkin, chia seeds, cod liver oil, vitamin supplements.
    Minimum protein level: 11%.
  4. Lamb recipe: Lamb, lamb liver, butternut squash, kale, chickpeas, cranberries, potato, chia seeds, vitamin supplements.
    Minimum protein level: 10%.

See the full meal details: Ollie Recipes.

Ollie meals review - best fresh dog food

How Do Ollie Meals Arrive?

Ollie meals are packed into a cardboard box and shipped to you once a week. They are covered with dry ice and insulation to keep them cold while in transit.

The meals themselves are in soft plastic packets. These packets are airtight which preserves the food for longer naturally, without the need for additional preservatives.

They keep in the fridge for 14 days unopened due to the airtight packaging. Once the seal is broken it can last for 5 days in the fridge.

You can also store it in the freezer for up to 3-4 months.

Along with your meals you get a plastic scoop that you use to portion out your dog’s meals. You also get a hard plastic container for storing leftover food in the fridge.

Meals are shipped for free in the US.

Ollie Reviews

Here’s a summary of what dogs and their parents thought of the meals online. On average Ollie received 4.4 out of 5 stars from 416 reviews on 2 platforms.

In terms of negative comments, a few users reported finding some grizzle in their dog’s meals. Ollie’s customer service have been responsive to those reports in order to sort those instances out.

The vast majority of reviewers say their dogs love Ollie meals and lick the bowl (sometimes twice!).

Many cited their customer service especially as being ‘outstanding’ . This was both in terms of dealing with any problems and with accommodating custom requests.

Here are some reviews from 2 Ollie fans:

Ollie meals review - which is the best fresh dog food delivery subscription?

Ollie meals review - which is the best fresh dog food delivery subscription?

How much do Ollie meals cost?

Ollie customizes your quote according to your dog’s details so it’s difficult to give an exact price range.

From our research we have put together the below prices as a guide.

I also completed our own Ollie quiz for sample dogs of different sizes. I’ve included the prices we were quoted next to the ranges.

Dog Size Ollie Price Estimate Our Dog’s Details Our Dog’s Quote
Small dog  $2-$4 a day Yorkshire Terrier
7 lbs
Pretty active
$2.70 a day
Medium dog $7-$8.50 a day English Springer Spaniel
40lbs
Pretty active
$6.90 a day
Large dog  $10-$13 a day Bullmastiff
110lbs
Pretty active
$10.90 a day
Personalised quote Ollie Quiz

 

There are a lot of things that could effect your quote, so we do recommend taking a moment to do their quiz to be sure. It only takes a minute and you’re not committed to moving ahead with the meals.

You also have the option for partial meal plans if you want to keep the cost down.

Ollie Offer

Get 50% off of your first Ollie meal:

Ollie Meal Discount

The Farmers dog review - best fresh dog food brand

The Farmer’s Dog Fresh Dog Food Deliveries

The founders of The Farmer’s Dog are 2 dog lovers who were tired of seeing dry, brown pellets being marketed as a ‘healthy’ food option for dogs.

They found these foods to be highly-processed and cooked to the point of being almost burnt.

Their mission was to redefine what pet food should look like and what it should do for our dogs.

Now it’s so good that apparently they even taste it themselves!

Does The Farmer’s Dog Have Good Quality Dog Meals?

The Farmer’s Dog is one of the best fresh dog food providers. They offer freshly prepared, nutritionally balanced dog meals free from additives and preservatives that are delivered to your door.

They also have a few main features which they pride themselves on:

1

1

Human-grade Ingredients

All their meats and vegetables are good enough for human consumption.

2

2

Gently Cooked Meals

Their meals are never cooked at extremely high temperatures but instead they are gently cooked and frozen straight away to preserve the nutrients.

 

3

3

Strict Safety Standards

Their foods are prepared in USDA kitchens to ensure the highest quality and safety standards.

4

4

Meals Designed by Veterinary Nutritionists

Like Ollie, their meals are designed by veterinary nutritionists.

This is to make sure that they are offering the right balance of ingredients and the right nutrients for your pup.

5

5

Personalised Meal Packets With Your Dog’s Name

Just because it’s always nice to see your name.

What Meal Options Does The Farmer’s Dog Offer?

You have to complete their quiz to see these meal options online, but here’s a snapshot of what each one contains:

  1. Turkey recipe: USDA Turkey, Chickpeas, Carrot, Broccoli, Parsnip, Spinach, Fish Oil, TFD Nutrient Blend. Min protein level: 9%
  2. Beef recipe: USDA beef, Sweet Potato, Lentils, Carrot, USDA Beef Liver, Kale, Sunflower Seeds, Fish Oil, TFD Nutrient Blend. Min protein level: 11%
  3. Pork recipe: USDA Pork, Sweet Potato, Potato, Green Beans, Cauliflower, USDA Pork Liver, Fish Oil, TFD Nutrient Blend. Min protein level: 9%

The Farmers dog review - best fresh dog food brand

How do The Farmer’s Dog Meals Arrive?

The meals arrive in soft plastic packets with your pup’s name on them.

These are packed into a cardboard box with dry ice and insulation to keep them fresh while in transit.

You initially receive 2 weeks’ worth of food so that you can start your dog slowly on it. Then you can set your preferred delivery frequency anywhere between 7-56 days.

The meals can be stored in the fridge for 4 days or in the freezer for 4 months. They also provide a disposable cardboard tray and lid for storing leftovers.

The Farmer’s Dog Testimonials

The Farmer’s Dog got an average of 4.6 out of 5 stars from 1,110 reviews.

Most dogs absolutely loved the food and looked forward to mealtime, even the picky eaters. A small handful had a bad reaction to the food but this can happen with any diet change.

The Farmer’s Dog fans had a lot of praise for their customer service which they said  ‘went above and beyond’ in some cases.

One customer’s dog passed away and The Farmer’s Dog sent them flowers to say they were sorry for their loss.

Here are some reviews from happy customers of The Farmer’s Dog.

Shelby W says:

The Farmers Dog review - best fresh dog food - Shelby W

Doroteya S says:

The Farmers Dog review - best fresh dog food - Doroteya S

Is The Farmer’s Dog Food Expensive?

The Farmer’s Dog prices are similar to the prices of other fresh dog food delivery services. It is more expensive than dried dog food but this is to be expected with meals that are a very different quality to traditional kibble.

Below are some price ranges which you can use as a guide. As the quotes are customised to your dog’s needs, we recommend taking their quick quiz to get a customised quote.

Dog Size The Farmer’s Dog Price Estimate
Small dog $2-5 a day
Medium dog $7-8 a day
Large dog $9-12 a day
Quiz for personalised quote The Farmer’s Dog Quiz

The Farmer’s Dog Starter Offer

Get 50% off of your first meal from The Farmer’s Dog:

The Farmer’s Dog Discount 

 

Ollie or The Farmer’s Dog, Which is Best?

Both offer great quality dog meals and have rave reviews from happy customers. The main difference between them is that Ollie has a bit more variety to choose from. They offer 4 meal options and also 4 dog snacks, while The Farmer’s Dog has 3 recipes to choose from and no snacks yet.

In terms of the recipes themselves, some dog owners may prefer to have the option of a chicken and lamb recipe, in which case they would choose Ollie.

Others may be happy with a pork recipe, (which Ollie does not have) in which case The Farmer’s Dog would be the best choice. Both have turkey and beef recipes.

Ollie’s packaging is also a little more convenient as they provide a scoop for portioning out the food. They also offer a hard plastic tray for storing the leftovers in the fridge.

On the other hand The Farmer’s Dog offers more flexibility. They take into account a large number of health conditions and allergies your dog may have when planning their meals.

They also allow you to choose exactly how often you want your deliveries to arrive. And they can even deliver to holiday addresses within the US.

When looking at the protein content in their meals, both Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog offer between 9-11% minimum protein levels. So they are similar in this regard.

Since each provide quality, human-grade ingredients, meals formulated by veterinary nutritionists, customised to your dog’s needs, and delivered to your door, I would recommend either one.

Whichever you try, I hope that they give you a healthier, happier dog.

Starter Offers

Get 50% off of your first meal from The Farmer’s Dog:

The Farmer’s Dog Discount 

Get 50% off your first order from Ollie Meals too:

Ollie Meals Discount

You also get a 30-day full money back guarantee with your first box.

Get FREE Phonics Flashcards

Grab our phonics letter pack today!

Join our weekly newsletter and get the best of our fun learning activities delivered straight to your inbox

newsletter printable
  • 15 first letter sounds
  • Initial sounds
  • Learn to read first words