Nom Nom vs Ollie: Which Fresh Dog Food is Better?

2
This article contains affiliate links: see more
best fresh dog meals - best fresh dog food delivery services

Sophie Anderson

A few years ago, most dog parents wouldn’t think twice about giving their dog canned or dry dog food from the shops. After all it’s ‘just food’ and it’s designed for dogs.

Recently however, animal experts have been looking more closely at the ingredients in kibble and what they found was surprising.

Not only do they often contain a high number of additives and preservatives, to give it a longer shelf life, but the base ingredients can be low quality as well.

Meat by-products and fillers are often used instead of quality meats. The ingredients are then cooked at very high temperatures which can remove a lot of the nutrients from the foods.

All this helps keep the food prices cheaper and a longer storage life, which is more convenient for dog owners. But it doesn’t do much for dogs’ health.

More pet owners are even starting to attribute their dog’s ongoing health problems to the ingredients in their food. And as a result they’re making the switch to fresh dog food.

Here we compare 2 of the best fresh dog food delivery services Ollie and Nom Nom.

Both offer meals made with human-grade ingredients that promise to be preservative and chemical free. They’re freshly prepared for your pup, portioned and delivered to your door each week or every few weeks.

Find out more about each service including their ingredients, meals offered, dog owners’ reviews and more.

  • Is Fresh Food Good for Picky Dogs?
  • What’s the Best Fresh Dog Food?
  • Comparison Table: Nom Nom vs Ollie
  • In-Depth Ollie Review
  • In-Depth Nom Nom Review
  • Which is Better Nom Nom or Ollie?

Is Fresh Dog Food Good for Picky Dogs?

Fresh dog foods have been lapped up by even the pickiest of dogs. Owners frequently report that they literally licked the bowl. This speaks to the quality of the food in the meals.

These dog meals are prepared with fresh, human-grade ingredients which are preservative free and stored in the freezer or fridge until served. They’re formulated especially with dogs’ long term nutritional needs in mind, often by veterinary nutritionists.

Fresh dog food delivery services prepare the meals, then they portion them into plastic packets and deliver them to your door in an insulated box. They work on a subscription basis so that you can receive regular deliveries, usually every week or every two weeks.

These services give dog owners the convenience of not having to prepare fresh meals every day for their pup or worry about their getting the right balance of nutrients for their needs. They don’t even need to go out to buy the foods as they come straight to the door.

Fresh Dog Food Benefits

Nom Nom and Ollie are 2 of the best fresh dog food services and each can offer a number of health benefits to your dog such as:

  1. Healthier stools and digestion
  2. Helping develop a shiny coat
  3. Better energy levels
  4. Better smelling breath and body odors
  5. Maintaining a healthy weight
  6. Prevention of diet-related health issues and increasing life-span

A recent study found that feeding dogs fresh dog meals as opposed to dry dog food could increase their life expectancy by as much as 3 years.

Nom Nom vs Ollie: Comparison Table

Ingredient quality Human-grade ingredients
Meats sourced from US farms
Hormone-free certified meats
Meats sourced from farms in the US and Australia
Free from Preservatives
Hormones
Fillers or ‘protein meals’
Animal by-products
Preservatives
Hormones
Artificial flavors
Fillers
Animal by-products
Price (USD)

(Price ranges are estimates)

$3-$13 a day
(quotes are based on your dog’s size and details)
$2-$13 per day
(quotes are based on your dog’s size and details)
Shipping cost Free shipping in the US Free shipping in the US
Meals personalised based on your dog’s: Breed
Weight
Age
Gender
Body condition
Sex
Number of specific health conditions
Breed
Current and ideal weight
Age
Gender
Body shape
Spayed or neutered
Level of energy
Current food type
Allergy to ingredients
Who formulates the dog meals? Board-certified veterinary nutritionist Board-certified veterinary nutritionist
Fresh meal options Beef Mash
Chicken Chow
Pork Potluck
Turkey Fare
Healthy Beef Eats
Healthy Turkey Feast
Chicken Goodness
Tasty Lamb Fare
Treat Options Beef Jerky
Chicken Jerky
Savory Beef Strips
Sweet Potato Slices
Tasty Chicken Strips
Trusty Turkey Strips
Meet AAFCO and USDA standards Yes Yes
Meal storage 8 days in the fridge
6 months in the freezer
Store meals in the freezer and defrost packets as you need them.
Reviews 4.4 stars from 1,079 reviews  4.5 stars from 412 reviews
Special offers 50% Off Your First Box:

Nom Nom 50% off

 

50% Off Your First Box:

Ollie Pets 50% Discount

Websites Nom Nom Ollie Meals

Ollie review - best fresh dog food delivery service - ollie meals review - my ollie review

My Ollie Meals Review

Ollie was started in 2016 but a group of dog owners and lovers in New York who are passionate about making healthy food more easily available to dogs.

They want dogs’ food to help them live longer lives, have more energy and give them the nutrition they need to be healthy.

Is My Ollie a Good Quality Dog Food?

Ollie’s meals contain good levels of protein along with fresh vegetables and some carbs. They have both grain and grain-free options with their meals.

As they are designed by veterinary nutritionists to be carefully balanced, they provide high nutritional value to dogs. They also personalise each dog’s requirements according to their details.

Their meals include:

  • Human-grade ingredients.
  • Hormone-free meats from US and Australian farms in their meals, free from fillers.
  • Preservative and artificial flavor free meals.
  • Veterinary nutritionists formulate meals and check they have all the vitamins and minerals needed.
  • Gentle cooking ensures that their foods retain as many ingredients as they can.

How Do I Order Ollie Meals?

To get started you can go to Ollie’s website and take their quiz which has 9 questions about your pup.

They ask for things like your dog’s breed, weight and age so that they can calculate how much they should be eating each day.

After you’ve provided this they will send you a quote along with some meal suggestions. You can either go with their suggestions or choose your own preference from their 4 meals:

  1. Healthy Beef Eats
  2. Healthy Turkey Feast
  3. Chicken Goodness
  4. Tasty Lamb Fare

Delivery Frequency

Your meals come every 2 weeks and are shipped for free in the US.

How Do Ollie Meals Arrive?

The food packets arrive in an insulated cardboard box, padded with dry ice. This keeps the meals frozen while in transit.

You can then transfer the meals to the freezer. Place any meals you will need into the fridge 24 hours before serving. They keep in the fridge for 14 days unopened and 5 days if the seal is broken.

They don’t need reheating, the meals will be ready to serve when they’re defrosted.

The food packets themselves are soft plastic pouches. The food is slightly mashed so that the meals are compact and so that they take up very little space in the fridge or freezer which is convenient for dog owners storing many days’ worth of meals.

They give you a plastic scoop for portioning out your dog’s meals. Leftover food from the packet can be stored in a hard plastic container that they provide.

Ollie review - best fresh dog food delivery service - ollie meals review - my ollie review

How Much Does Ollie Cost?

The exact price varies depending on your dog’s details, which you enter during the questionnaire but as a guide it can range between $2-$13 per day.

We have put together the below price ranges for different dog sizes, though these are just estimates:

  • Small dog (10-20lbs): $2-4 a day
  • Medium dog (30-40lbs): $7-8.50 a day
  • Large dog(50-70lbs): $10-13 a day

It takes a minute to do the quiz if you want to get a personalised quote: Ollie quiz.

Money-back guarantee

Ollie also offer you a 100% money back guarantee on your first box, which makes it a risk-free way of trying it out.

Ollie Dog Food Reviews

Ollie got an average of 4.5 stars out of 5 from 412 reviews on 2 independent websites.

Dog parents found that even fussy eaters enjoyed the meals and looked forward to mealtimes. Many saw health benefits to their pups as well as increased energy.

Observations like their dogs developing shinier coats, regular stools and fewer smells were made too.

They found it incredibly convenient that the meals were delivered to their door. The soft plastic packaging and compact packets meant that they could fit them all in their freezer for storage.

Here’s what some Ollie dog parents had to say:

Super convenient! Plus, my furbabys love it! I have a VERY picky 8 year old Maltese and he licks his bowl clean everytime! I also have a 4 month Maltipoo- who’s a mini garbage disposal (eats everything!) Loves this as much as my picky Maltese! Would definitely recommend… Amanda from Influenster

Ollie keeps my ladies regular ?

Ollie is fantastic dog food. Before giving my dogs Ollie I used canned and dry food, and my girls would have diarrhea all the time. After about a year of giving my girls Ollie can’t remember last the time either of them had a diarrhea episode.

Liza from Trustpilot

Get 50% off your first box!

Ollie Pets Discount

Their first box is also covered by a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Nom nom now review - best fresh dog food delivery service - human grade dog food 1

Nom Nom Dog Food Review

Nom Nom was founded in 2015 by a group of dog enthusiasts after one of their puppies, an Australian Shepherd, was diagnosed with a compromised immune system.

As more focus was already shifting onto dog’s health through nutrition, her vet recommended a fresh diet to help with her problems. And apparently it did.

Making fresh meals also took up a lot of time though and there was a lot of effort to check that each meal had the right nutrients for their pup in the long term.

The founders wondered why there wasn’t a healthier solution to dry dog food on the market when they saw fresh dog food had such clear benefits to their health.

So they founded Nom Nom.

Why Is Nom Nom One of the Best Dog Foods?

Nom Nom’s meals are made with fresh, quality ingredients and are designed by veterinary nutritionists to ensure they meet dogs’ long term needs. Their goal is to help dogs with their overall health and wellness.

They have a number of big advantages over some traditional dog foods:

  • Fresh, human-grade ingredients are used in their meals.
  • Meats are hormone-free and sourced from US farms.
  • Low temperature cooking of meals in order to retain more nutrients in the meals.
  • No preservatives or fillers are added or used.
  • Meals are formulated by veterinary nutritionists to ensure that they meet your dog’s nutritional needs.

How Do I Order Nom Nom Dog Meals?

To get started you answer 7 main questions about your dog which include breed, weight and health conditions.

Nom Nom use this information to calculate the calorie intake and nutritional needs of your dog.

They will provide you with a quote for the amount of dog food your pup will need each day.

Along with some suggestions of which of their meals they will enjoy. You can choose your own meals if you prefer and you have the option to rotate the recipes for your dog. Their 4 meal options are:

  1. Beef Mash
  2. Chicken Chow
  3. Pork Potluck
  4. Turkey Fare

If your dog has health issues you can add these to your account and you’re also encouraged to contact customer services to discuss their needs.

Once you have selected the meals that you prefer you can get started.

Nom nom now review - best fresh dog food delivery service - human grade dog food

Nom Nom’s Transition Plan

Adjusting to a new food can be a big change for dogs, particularly on their stomachs. For that reason Nom Nom automatically start you off with a 2 week transition plan.

During this time you’re given 50% of your dog’s meals which you can mix with their current food to help their bodies get used to it. Afterwards you can continue with full meal portions.

Delivery Frequency

Following the transition plan, you can set your delivery frequency to every week, 2 weeks or 4 weeks, as you prefer.

How Do Nom Nom Meals Arrive?

Nom Nom’s meals arrive in an insulated cardboard box with ice packs to keep the food cool.

Once you get them you can transfer most of them to the freezer where they will keep for 3 months. The meals also last for 8 days in the fridge.

Are Nom Nom’s Meals Pre-Portioned

Yes. A big advantage with Nom Nom is that they pre-portion your dog’s meals so that 1 packet is 1 meal.

This is very convenient for dog parents as it means you don’t have to worry about measuring out the right portion of food from a packet and then storing leftovers.

The meals themselves come in soft, airtight, plastic packets which are compact, so that they take up as little space as possible in the fridge or freezer.

Nom nom review - Nom nom now review - best fresh dog food delivery service - human grade dog food 2

What Does Nom Nom Cost?

The quote you will receive will depend on the breed and size of dog that you have, along with other details.

As such it’s not possible to give an exact price, however we put together the below price ranges as a guide.

They are an estimate of the quote levels you may get:

  • Small dog (10-20lbs): $3-4 a day
  • Medium dog (30-40lbs): $5-6 a day
  • Large dog(50-70lbs): $7-13 a day

It takes a minute to do the quiz if you want to get a personalised quote: Nom Nom quiz.

Money Back Guarantee

Nom Nom offer you a 30 day money-back guarantee, so if you’re not happy with your first box you can always request a refund.

Nom Nom Customer Reviews

Nom Nom got an average of 4.4 stars out of 5 from 1,079 reviews across 2 independent websites.

Dog owners loved the meals which looked good enough for people to eat as well.

Even those with dogs who were picky eaters commented that they took to the meals immediately.

Many also reported seeing a number of health benefits in their dog, like more energy, less dandruff, in some cases an improvement in on-going health conditions.

A few reviewers commented that their dogs reacted badly to the foods at first. This can happen when you make a big change to their diet and they may need some more time to adjust.

Here’s what some Nom Nom dog parents had to say:

This food is fantastic! You can see how tall and fresh it is. My dog is so much healthier and has lost 5 lbs since starting this diet. Highly recommend! Gabriella from Trustpilot

Since I’ve been using it, my dog literally dances every time I pull one of those packets out of their fridge. I love the fact that Nom Nom is using fresh ingredients. When I look at that dog food, I can actually see the meat and the vegetable, and I can tell what the ingredients are. Karlene from consumeraffairs.com

 

As well as a 30-day money back guarantee, Nom Nom offers:

Nom Nom 50% Off Your First Meal

Ollie or Nom Nom, Which is Best?

Ollie and Nom Nom are both equally good fresh dog food services. They have some minor differences which dog owners may have a preference on.

Nom Nom creates meals in individual portions so that 1 packet is 1 portion. There is no need for dog parents to spoon it out and store leftovers. It also offers fresh cat meal options and sources sources its meats from US farms only (Ollie gets meats from the US and Australia).

Ollie on the other hand offers a slightly lower price starting point for the smallest dogs at $2 instead of $3 a day. They also ask a few more questions when customising meals, including about any allergies. They have 4 snack options instead of 2 and their packets are very compact for storing in the freezer.

Both Nom Nom and Ollie offer quality fresh dog meals with human-grade ingredients which have been formulated by veterinary nutritionists.

They also offer the convenience of delivering the meals to your door and each offer free shipping to the US.

Whichever you choose, I highly recommend fresh dog meals as a healthy nutritious option for your pup.

Start with Nom Nom and get 50% off their first box:

Nom Nom 50% Off 

Or try Ollie for 50% Off too:

Ollie Pets 50% Discount

Both offer a 30 day money-back guarantee.

Get FREE Phonics Flashcards

Grab our phonics letter pack today!

Join our weekly newsletter and get the best of our fun learning activities delivered straight to your inbox

newsletter printable
  • 15 first letter sounds
  • Initial sounds
  • Learn to read first words